English   105
esign
 Exchange
 
Greg:It is a rather hot day, O Socrates; it is quite humid, there is no breeze, and there are no trees under which to find shelter from the suns piercing rays. Let me get you a cool Miller Lite, in order that we may find refuge from this summer heat.
Socrates:Thank you, Greg, for a Miller Lite sounds quite refreshing about now. I drink it for the great taste, you know.
Greg:So I have heard, but do you know that you should drink it because it is less filling?
Socrates:Is that so?
Greg:Yes. The average light beer has around 110 calories, whereas Miller Lite has only 96, which allows you to drink it without slowing you down.
Socrates:So you're saying I should drink it because it's less filling, then?
Greg:It would appear so.
Socrates:Let me ask you this. Is water not less filling than Miller Lite? In fact, does water not have zero calories?
Greg:This is true, but water is not a beer.
Socrates:But you would agree with me that it is less filling?
Greg:Yes, I would.
Socrates:And would you not also agree that Diet Coke, with just one calorie, would also be less filling than Miller Lite and it's 96 calories?
Greg:Yes, I would also agree to that, but again, it is not a fine-tasting brew.
Socrates:And toilet water, would you agree with me that toilet water also contains fewer calories than Miller Lite?
Greg:O, Socrates, I do not see where you are going with this, and I am rather disgusted right about now. Why do you ask me of such things?
Socrates:I know one would not normally drink toilet water, but since it is composed of mostly water (unless you use a Vanish Drop-in), would you not say it has fewer calories than Miller Lite?
Greg:I suppose.
Socrates:But you would not drink it for its taste?
Greg:I would think not!
Socrates:But it is less filling than Miller Lite. Surely, you should drink it because it is less filling. Am I not right?
Greg:Never have I tried such a thing, less filling or not.
Socrates:So, you would avoid toilet water because of its taste?
Greg:Absolutely.
Socrates:Then you would concede that the taste of your drink is important.
Greg:Yes, I suppose I would, but not as important as it being less filling.
Socrates:But we have just seen that Miller Lite is better tasting than toilet water, but you would choose toilet water over Miller Lite because it is less filling?
Greg:Certainly not.
Socrates:Then you must agree that you drink Miller Lite because of its great taste?
Greg:Wow, I believe I would, Socrates, but all of this philosophical debate has left my mind confused.
Socrates:Not to worry, Greg, I have another Miller Lite on hand for each of us.